The landscape of the retail industry is in the midst of a quiet transformation, marking a significant shift in consumer behaviors and market dynamicsAs we approach the end of 2024, data indicates a slight decline in the e-commerce market share within the fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) sector, down by 0.6%, while traditional brick-and-mortar sales have seen a modest increase of 1.8%. This marks the first instance of negative growth in the e-commerce market, prompting analysts to dig deeper into the factors driving this unexpected trend.

During the recent Spring Festival period, a time when consumer spending typically peaks, certain retail channels showcased resilience, with department stores and convenience stores recording sales growth of 5.2% and 16.1% respectivelyNotably, these figures surpassed or closely approached the 5.8% growth in online retail, suggesting a resurgence in the traditional retail sector after years of pressure from online competitors.

For over a decade, e-commerce has been the darling of the retail world, expanding rapidly while physical stores struggled to maintain their footing

Advertisements

In 2010, the total online retail sales in China were merely 513.1 billion yuan, accounting for only 3.3% of the total social retail salesFast forward to 2023, and this figure ballooned to a staggering 15 trillion yuan, capturing a 32.7% share of the marketMeanwhile, the market share of the top 100 retail enterprises decreased from 8.86% to 4.34%, a stark indication of the challenges faced by physical retailers.

Today, we witness the first signs of a “shift in power dynamics” in retail, as consumers begin to appreciate the tangible experiences offered by physical storesPromises of the lowest prices in the online marketplace are wavering, and shoppers are discovering that offline retailers can provide high quality and competitively priced productsThis could signal a future where online and offline shopping coexist more harmoniously, leveraging each channel's unique strengths rather than constantly pitting them against one another.

Price advantage has long been the cornerstone of online shopping's rapid ascent

Advertisements

On average, products sold online are 5% to 15% cheaper than their in-store counterparts, a discrepancy that is pronounced in categories like electronics, clothing, and daily necessitiesTo amplify this price advantage, e-commerce platforms have engaged in aggressive price wars, striving to dominate the market through low-cost strategies.

However, as businesses compete for the title of “lowest price”, the market faces growing pressuresThis competitive strain leads to a phenomenon dubbed "pricing internalization," where the race to the bottom diminishes profitability for many sellersThe ability to sustain the lowest prices is becoming increasingly rare, forcing many businesses, especially smaller e-commerce sellers, to resort to dubious practices to maintain their margins, such as cutting corners on product quality.

In a revealing example from Jiangsu's market regulation agency, an investigation into online sales of down products found instances of businesses substituting genuine down with inferior materials to save costs, effectively halving production expenses

Advertisements

This alarming trend has become a well-known secret in certain markets, evolving into a troubling norm within the industry.

The convenience and variety offered by online shopping have also fueled its rapid growthE-commerce platforms aggregate countless sellers and product types, vastly outnumbering any physical store's inventoryThis concentration of product information allows consumers to easily compare items and make informed decisions, significantly speeding up the shopping processThe freedom and leisurely pace of online shopping contrast sharply with the sometimes overwhelming atmosphere of traditional retail, further enticing shoppers online.

Nevertheless, with supply saturation and increasingly complex algorithms, some consumers are shifting towards a more minimalist shopping approach, inadvertently creating a breathing space for physical stores, which usually have a limited amount of inventory

• The Inability of Jinshan Cloud to Stand Alone
• The Rise of A-Shares and the AI Investment Boom
• SK On: A Strategic Shift with Strong Prospects
• The UK’s Economic Dilemma: Inflation
• The Golden Era of Gold

Outlets like Sam's Club, Pang Dong Lai, and Miniso exemplify this shift, simplifying the shopping experience and helping consumers narrow down their choices.

Since last year, many physical retailers have noted a resurgence in sales, signaling a turning tideThe Bain & Company 2024 China Shopper Report highlights that from January to September of 2024, overall sales in retail's offline channels grew by 1.8%, with small-sized retail formats notably outperforming larger storesSupermarkets and small supermarkets experienced a growth rate increase from 4% in the previous year to 6%, while the performance of general retailers dropped by 5%.

This evolution hints at a potential “counterattack” from traditional retail channels, as smaller formats become increasingly favored for their convenience and proximity to consumersThe rise of discount stores, especially, cannot be overlooked; these outlets cater directly to consumers’ growing awareness of value, outpacing non-discount stores in sales growth

The market now sees the emergence of two types of discount stores: hard-discounters, which capitalize on scale and operational efficiency, and soft-discounters that focus on selling near-expiry products at reduced prices.

The meteoric rise of discount outlets is an answer to consumers’ growing prudence toward spending, aptly reflected in the boom of outlet shopping in 2024. Reports indicate an explosion of new outlet projects and the transformation of existing commercial entities to outlet models, with major players like Shanshan Commercial Group and Shazhi Chuan Group investing heavily in this trend across various cities.

The speed of growth for discount stores offers a respite in the face of traditional offline pricing affecting consumer perceptionRetail stakeholders are clearly betting on this shift, indicating a robust confidence in the resurgence of offline shopping.

When considering shopping experiences, offline retail inherently offers a sense of security and reliability

This characteristic becomes especially pronounced as price-sensitive online shoppers face uncertainty about the products they receiveThe surge in return rates across e-commerce platforms, particularly in the apparel sector, underscores this shift in consumer sentimentReports have shown that the return rates for women's clothing on various platforms rose by an alarming 10% in 2024, with some shops experiencing return rates as high as 75%. Major reasons for returns include discrepancies in sizing, quality control issues, impulse buys, and challenges surrounding logistics and customer service.

This evolving landscape has placed significant pressure on businesses' profit margins, forcing many female apparel online retailers to shutter their operations.

With increasing skepticism toward e-commerce influencers and live-stream selling, consumers are reorienting their focus back to the quality and value of the products themselves

This trend highlights an important aspect of physical retail: the unique advantages offered through tangible shopping experiences, personal interactions, and curated product selections that can't easily be replicated onlineThe strengthening of offline retail is built on these essential elements, which form a solid foundation for its recovery.

In conclusion, the brick-and-mortar sector exhibits an evolving narrative as it seeks to adapt and thrive amidst changing consumer prioritiesRetailers are recalibrating their commercial strategies and are increasingly focusing on price adjustments, enhancing operational efficiencies, and fundamentally reinventing their business modelsThe emergence of bulk snack stores, operating with minimal overhead by bypassing traditional distributors, is emblematic of these changes.

These retailers operate on a model where they acquire goods directly from manufacturers and focus exclusively on snack wholesale and retail, a shift that emphasizes high value and low-profit margins while leveraging scalability

During the past two years, snack bulk stores have emerged as a significant player in the offline retail scene, demonstrating impressive growth.

By sidestepping conventional distribution routes, these stores not only reduce costs for consumers but also import an immediacy to the shopping experience typically absent in online retailFor instance, the snack brand "Snack It!" began its journey in Changsha in 2017 and, as of June 2024, has expanded its operations to over 10,000 stores nationwideSimilarly, other brands have followed suit, capitalizing on this new market segment.

Furthermore, many brands have synchronized their offline and online promotions, ensuring consistent discounts and offers that further engage consumersRecent sales events like the "Double Eleven" illustrate this strategy, where both online and offline channels coordinated promotional efforts, sometimes yielding prices better than those found in online flagship stores